Sunday, November 22, 2026

Americas 250th Birthday Cinemathon #59: Frost/Nixon (2008)

 


Richard Nixon, the 37th President of the United States, has been the poster boy for executive corruption, a villain for the boomer generation. The main cause is the Watergate scandal, when five of Nixon’s guys broke into the headquarters of Democrat National Committee in 1972 and bugged the place, then came back later to repair the equipment and were caught. This event came to light, and many people went to prison or lost office because of it since there was a cover-up. Nixon himself faced was looking at possible impeachment, but resigned as President in 1974 to save the nation further scandal (Gerald Ford gave him a full pardon for all presidential actions). He became something of a villain in popular culture, even making it into a couple Marvel Comics, but did gain more nuanced attention from historians later on. He’s still received negatively overall, but I do find the fixation on Watergate to seem a bit quaint considering all the bugging and spying on citizens and political opponents, not to mention all the lawfare, that the government has been involved in this century.

Still, Watergate was an eye-opening shock for the American public, which had largely been kept ignorant of some of the ugly dealings behind the scenes in government. Frost/Nixon, Ron Howard’s adaptation of Peter Morgan’s play of the same name, deals with some of the aftermath of the Watergate scandal. In 1977, British television personality David Frost got Nixon to sit down for eleven interviews sessions which, edited down to four 90-minute episodes, revolutionized the interview format. Frost pressed Nixon hard on the scandal, even referencing previously unused evidence.

The main point of the movie is that the interviews ensured that Watergate was not forgotten, that Nixon would be remembered as a culprit. This was helped by the fact that Frost, having to outbid the major networks, heavily invested his own money in the interviews, meaning he worked extra hard to make sure the program was revealing. Ron Howard was keen to cast the two leads with the same two actors that played them on Broadway, so Michael Sheen is David Frost. He doesn’t have to change his British accent, because Frost was indeed a British host. He was part of a wave of satirical programs in 1960s Britain, and eventually found his way to American television as well. Frost/Nixon overplays him as a light entertainer, though his playboy personality isn’t too far off if one goes into his varied dating history at the time. One of his longer relationships was with Caroline Cushing Graham, a Vanity Fair editor played in the film by Rebecca Hall as a very supportive girlfriend.

David Frost (Michael Sheen) first meets Caroline Channing (Rebecca Hall) on the
plane to the States. Actually, they were already dating years before the interviews.

As said a couple of sentences ago, the movie gives him more of an uphill arc by having him start as an out-of-his-depth entertainer. Whereas in real life Frost had all his information and sources meticulously put together before the first interview, here he struggles and gets constantly outplayed by Nixon. They were also already acquainted with each other, but here they meet for the first time so it comes off as former world leader Nixon looming over the small TV host. Sheen finally matches up to his opponent when the former president gives him a drunken midnight phone call. This call, which never happened, has Nixon get under Frost’s skin and then unwittingly drive him to kick into high gear and become a truly serious interviewer. One additional not-quite-inaccuracy is that the time between the breaking of the Watergate scandal in 1972 and the interviews themselves seems to pass in the space of a year. Actually, the film just moves forward quickly without giving a good indicator that years have passed.


Carrying over from Broadway like Sheen, Frank Langella plays Richard Nixon. He does a good enough job, making Nixon sympathetic despite his complicity in several questionable Presidential actions. Indeed, Nixon comes off as a bit of a sad figure, in one scene trying to interest a crowd in amusing anecdotes of his presidency, only to have them sit quietly until they have an opportunity to plague him with questions about Watergate. While Langella is a great actor, he does run into the same problem as other Nixon performers in that it’s hard to play him without sounding like a parody. Nixon had such a distinctive voice that an actor either has to ignore it and sound inauthentic or imitate it and sound goofy compared to the rest of the cast.

Going back to the accuracy of the interviews, in general they’re correct, with Nixon at first being able to avoid any admission of wrongdoing. The drama of course, is elevated. When Frost finally steps up his game, the damning moments against Nixon are played as gotcha moments. While this does add dramatic emotion, I feel it undercuts the most sinister part of the interviews. On the Huston Plan (which could potentially intern anti-war protestors in camps) Nixon said, “When the president does it, that means that it is not illegal” when questioned about some of his controversial actions. In the movie Langella’s Nixon says this in an outburst, then has a shocked “what did I just say” face. Sheen’s Frost then gives out a surprised “What?” In the real interview, Nixon said this line in a matter-of-fact way that revealed how presidents can view themselves as having a different level of accountability. To viewers, this was a shockingly blunt admission of guilt and contributed to his portrayal as a villainous figure. Also, the real Frost did not utter any surprised statement, but a calm, pointed follow up “By definition?”

The interview team: Bob Zelnick (Oliver Platt), David Frost,
James Reston (Sam Rockwell), and John Birt (Matthew Macfadyen)

The real thing that keeps me from giving the movie a high score, however, is that outside the two leads, I didn’t find the cast all too interesting. Sam Rockwell plays James Reston, a journalist who is very eager to nail Nixon. Having already covered Watergate, he assists Frost in his research. I think I found him annoying because he keeps getting angry and emotional whenever Frost fails to get Nixon to fess up to any wrongdoing. His book The Conviction of Richard Nixon was actually the basis of the stage play and movie. Jack Brennan (Kevin Bacon) is the most inaccurate of the characters. A decorated Marine, Brennan was Nixon’s chief of staff and stuck with the family long after the presidency ended. The real Brennan was reportedly a fun guy to be around and was very obliging towards Frost and his interview team. Here he’s a stick-in-the-mud who’s slavishly devoted to Nixon and comes up with tactics to protect the image of his favorite president (though the historical Brennan actually advised Nixon to be direct and honest in his answers). At one point he tries to have the interview cut off, but he never tried to do such a blatant defensive play.


Frost/Nixon is a fairly good movie, but not a particularly engaging one. It’s very much all about the two leads giving great performances. Still, it does have the most balanced depiction of Nixon in cinema.

Rating: 6/10

No comments:

Post a Comment