Showing posts with label movie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label movie. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 1, 2026

Americas 250th Birthday Cinemathon #33: Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee (2007)

 


This is another revision of an earlier review I made. This time, however, my opinion of the movie was greatly changed on my rewatch. Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee, a television movie from HBO, is based on Dee Brown’s famous history of the fall of the American Indians in the latter half of the 19th Century. Brown’s book is too widely focused to make a single movie, so HBO limited itself to the story of the Sioux, from their last great victory at Little Bighorn to the fallout of the Wounded Knee Massacre in 1890, charting their decline from a proud warrior people on the western plains to dependents on a reservation. Overall it’s a pretty accurate film, but accuracy does not always translate into a great movie.

The movie tries for a balanced account of events, though both of the primary protagonists are Sioux Indians. The first is Charles Eastman (Adam Beach). Eastman is the biggest inaccuracy of the movie. As in real life he has a Sioux father who converted to Christianity and changed his name to Jacob Eastman. For a while Charles, as Ohiyesa, lived with his mother’s people, but they were not part of the group under Sitting Bull, so Eastman’s presence at Little Bighorn is completely fictional. He was put in a mission school before having an American education program. Though the movie doesn't have him go to one of the controversial boarding schools, it still shows how Indian children were made to abandon their cultural heritage, down to adopting western names. The movie gets inaccurate with Eastman again, however, in giving him a close relationship with Henry Dawes which didn't exist, and also making him figure more in the other Sioux's lives earlier in the timeline.

What is true is that he was the first American Indian to master western medicine and became a doctor on the Great Sioux Reservation. At least in the movie his character is torn between two worlds. He can’t help but sympathize with his own people but also has a friendship with Senator Henry Dawes (Aidan Quinn) and a romantic relationship with poet and future wife Elaine Goodale (Anna Paquin, who played Rogue in the X-Men films). By the end of the movie he has grown disgusted with health conditions on the reservation as well as the misguided aspects of the Dawes Act, which forced the Sioux to become farmers and also sell off more of their already shrunken lands. Eastman was not present for most of the events in the movie and certainly did not have as many personal interactions with other major characters, but he is used to show the tensions the Sioux face between preserving some of their culture and adopting the whites’ ways.

Tuesday, November 8, 2022

Movie Review: All Quiet on the Western Front (2022)

 


All Quiet on the Western Front
is the third adaptation of Erich Maria Remarque's famous World War I novel, and surprisingly the first German one considering it is from the perspective of that nation's soldiers. Paul Baumer and his school chums enthusiastically sign up for the German Army and are sent to the Western Front in France. They soon lose their glorious and patriotic notions of war as they encounter filthy trench conditions and a string of murderous battles. Veteran soldiers try to help them adjust and survive, with Stanislaus Katczinsky taking personal responsibility for Paul. It's one of the most famous anti-war stories (though Remarque famously never explicitly stated it as such).

I've never read the novel and only watched the famous 1930 version, so I'll have to compare this latest offering to that one. I did read that Director Edward Berger cut out a few supporting characters and scenes and changed or added new ones to differentiate his interpretation. This leads to my main criticism. There's a subplot that follows real life figure Matthias Erzberger and his attempts to form an armistice and end the war. It and relevant scenes showing German generals do add more historical context, but personally the movie should have focused only on the frontline soldiers. Removing this scenes would have also trimmed it closer to a two hour film (then again, these scenes might be necessary considering many younger folks don't have the best grasp of history). As for other changes and additions, they manage to keep the spirit of themes from the novel and previous adaptations. Another criticism is the musical score. The composer went for more of a sound design style to create a sense of dread, but it can be obnoxious and ill-fitted to early scenes of new recruits smiling on their way to war.

Monday, September 12, 2022

Movie Review: Medieval (2022)

 

Medieval is a Czech film made in the English language and theatrically released in the States (it’s out as of the time of this review). The title is rather broad and simple (it’s like calling a film set within the last couple centuries Modern) but considering that the average American won’t know anything about the specific events depicted it’s just as well. I was drawn to this movie because it takes place in Bohemia, the land of my paternal ancestors. Czech director Petr Jakl focuses on the rise of Jan Zizka (Ben Foster), a famed Czech military hero, prior to the Hussite Wars (1418-1434). The Hussite Wars were a series of struggles within the Holy Roman Empire. These were centered in Bohemia, where theologian Jan Hus presaged the Protestant Reformation with his calls for church reform and an emphasis on Scripture over leading clergymen for authority.

Since Medieval’s narrative precedes the wars, Jan Hus is off to the side, but his criticisms of church and politics does tie into one of the story’s central conflicts, which is how the common people are victimized by the machinations of Papal and royal politics. In the early 15th Century the Roman Catholic Church is split between two popes, one in Rome and the other in France, and the title of Holy Roman Emperor is unoccupied. This results in violent chaos throughout Europe. In an attempt to reunite the Church under Rome and stabilize Europe, Lord Bores (Michael Caine) plans to have Zizka escort Bohemian King Wenceslas IV (Karl Roden) to Rome where he will be crowned Holy Roman Emperor. Scheming King Sigismund of Hungary (Matthew Goode) also has his eyes on the throne, and forms an antagonistic alliance with tyrannical Bohemian nobleman Rosenberg (Til Schweiger). In an attempt to neutralize Rosenberg, Lord Bores has Zizka abduct his French fiancĂ©e Catherine (Sophie Lowe). Thanks to a series of double-crosses and Sigismund’s own agenda, Zizka and his mercenaries end up allying with peasant rebels against Sigismund and his nasty mercenary leader Torak (Roland Moller). If you think this is hard to follow, you’re correct. If you don’t have any decent historical knowledge of this period in history you might find yourself lost.

Wednesday, June 15, 2022

Movie Review: Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee (2007)

 


Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee is based on Dee Brown’s famous history of the fall of the American Indians in the latter half of the 19th Century. It’s a television movie from HBO and focuses only on the sections dealing with the Sioux. The film starts with the last hurrah of the Sioux at Little Bighorn in 1876 and concludes with the fallout of the Wounded Knee Massacre in 1890, charting their decline from a proud warrior people on the western plains to dependents on a reservation. Overall it’s a pretty accurate film.

HBO tries to present a balanced account of events, though both of the primary protagonists are Sioux Indians. The first is Charles Eastman (Adam Beach, who has some internet meme fame as Slipknot, the man who can climb anything). Eastman was a Sioux youth whose father converted to Christianity. His father came to pick him up and send him to a school where he assumed Western values and his western name. He was the first American Indian to master western medicine and became a doctor on the Great Sioux Reservation. His character is torn between two worlds. He can’t help but sympathize with his own people but also has a friendship with Senator Henry Dawes (Aidan Quinn) and marriage with poet Elaine Goodale (Anna Paquin who played Rogue in the X-Men films). By the end of the movie he has grown disgusted with health conditions on the reservation as well as the misguided aspects of the Dawes Act, which will force them to become farmers and also sell off more of their already shrunken lands.