Hippensteel, Scott. Myths of the Civil War: The Fact, Fiction, and Science behind the Civil War’s Most-Told Stories. Lanham: Stackpole Books, 2021.
Scott
Hippensteel is an associate professor of earth sciences at the University of
North Carolina. If one wonders why a scientist wrote a book on the Civil War,
it should be noted that his specialties include geoarchaeology and micropaleontology.
Hippensteel himself is a Civil War buff and has sought to apply his specific
field to this historical era. Myths of
the Civil War does not deal with social issues like slavery’s importance or
strategic ones like who was really responsible for the Confederate defeat at
Gettysburg, but primarily with how historians and others who present the Civil
War have uncritically accepted soldiers’ metaphors as literal fact or the
objectivity of early photojournalism. Injecting his short book with bits of humor,
Hippensteel is able to scientifically challenge claims about the Civil War in
an engaging and entertaining fashion.
The first myth he challenges is that of the Civil War sniper, that thanks to advances in weapon technology, crack shots were able to hit generals like Sedgwick at Spotsylvania and Reynolds at Gettysburg with pinpoint accuracy. Studying physics and the capabilities of firearms at the time, Hippensteel convincingly argues that Civil War sharpshooters were not the equivalent of snipers and would either target clusters of men or work in teams to fill a general area with bullets.